Attorneys Eric Chaffin and Justin Joseph of Chaffin Luhana secured a $130,000 verdict for a client injured by a garbage truck. While the defense admitted liability shortly before trial, the case became a hard-fought battle over the extent of the plaintiff’s injuries and his credibility. Brendan Lupetin discussed the case with the victim’s attorneys on Just Verdicts podcast episode 49.
For any expectant couple, the birth of a first child is a moment of unparalleled anticipation. It is the culmination of months of preparation, dreams, and the careful stewardship of a new life. For “Sarah” and “Michael,” a young couple from the Pittsburgh area, the pregnancy had been textbook perfect. However, what should have been the happiest day of their lives turned into a harrowing ordeal that would forever alter the trajectory of their family.
When “Emily,” a 44-year-old bank manager from Westmoreland County, went in for a routine microdiscectomy to relieve back pain, she expected a quick recovery and a return to her quiet, private life. Instead, a catastrophic surgical error left her fighting for her life on the operating table.
The difference between a “bad result” and a medical mistake lies in the Standard of Care. A bad result is often a known risk or complication that occurred despite the doctor doing everything correctly. A medical mistake (negligence) occurs when a healthcare provider deviates from accepted medical standards, causing a preventable injury or death.
When you sign a consent form prior to a surgical procedure, it is an acknowledgment of risk, not a permission slip for negligence. In Pennsylvania, you cannot sign away your right to be treated with the proper Standard of Care. If the injury was caused by a preventable medical error, that signature does not stop you from filing a malpractice lawsuit.
If you are suffered an injury due to medical malpractice in Pennsylvania, and moved to another state after the incident occured, you must file the lawsuit in Pennsylvania. Thanks to modern technology, meetings and depositions can typically be handled remotely. Be sure you understand how PA laws apply to your case.
Although the time limit for a child’s medical malpractice claim does not start until they turn 18, the “Parents’ Claim” generally has a strict 2-year deadline from the date of the injury. If you wait until the child is older, you may be permanently barred from recovering the millions of dollars spent on their NICU care, surgeries, and therapy during childhood.
There is a common misconception that non-profit organizations like UPMC and AHN can’t be sued in cases of medical malpractice. This is generally false for the major hospitals, as they are legally separate from the state. They cannot hide behind “governmental immunity” to avoid paying for catastrophic mistakes.
Patients often assume that they can’t sue for malpractice if they didn’t follow the doctor’s recovery instructions to the letter. A legal rule called Modified Comparative Negligence states that as long as the doctor or hospital is at least 50% responsible for your injury, you can recover damages.
For decades, the “Standard of Care” in medicine has been defined by what a reasonably competent physician would do in similar circumstances. Historically, this standard protected doctors who followed the pack. If most doctors weren’t using a specific technology, you generally couldn’t be sued for not using it either. But we are approaching a legal tipping point.
In the near future, a defense strategy is likely to emerge in courtrooms across Pennsylvania and the United States: The “Black Box” Defense. The scenario is straightforward, but the legal implications are not. As Artificial Intelligence becomes entrenched in our healthcare systems, this tension between clinical judgment and algorithmic reliance is set to become one of the most contested battlegrounds in medical malpractice law.
In the realm of medical malpractice, few cases illustrate the fragility of health and the catastrophic impact of a single decision like the case of “Eleanor.” An 80-year-old widow residing in Erie, Pennsylvania, Eleanor was the picture of vitality and independence—until a trip to the emergency room for severe constipation turned into a life-threatening nightmare.
